5 Scary Babysitter Stories That Will Make You Afraid to Be Home Alone

One candle for every story

1. 1 - told, candle out
2. 2 - told, candle out
3. 3 - told, candle out
4. 4 - told, candle out
5. 5 - told, candle out
6. 6 - told, candle out
7. 7 - told, candle out
8. 8 - told, candle out
9. 9 - told, candle out
10. 10 - told, candle out
11. 11 - told, candle out
12. 12 - told, candle out
13. 13 - told, candle out
14. 14 - told, candle out
15. 15 - told, candle out
16. 16 - told, candle out
17. 17 - told, candle out
18. 18 - told, candle out
19. 19 - told, candle out
20. 20 - being told, candle burning
21. 21 - still to tell, candle lit
22. 22 - still to tell, candle lit
23. 23 - still to tell, candle lit
24. 24 - still to tell, candle lit

Story 40 of 47. 39 told, 7 still waiting.