Episode 425 · 51 min · Let's Not Meet: A True Horror Podcast

16x03: Gatsby and Daisy

Published Jan 19, 2026by Cryptic CountyHorror

One candle for every story

  1. 1 - told, candle out
  2. 2 - told, candle out
  3. 3 - told, candle out
  4. 4 - told, candle out
  5. 5 - told, candle out
  6. 6 - told, candle out
  7. 7 - told, candle out
  8. 8 - told, candle out
  9. 9 - told, candle out
  10. 10 - told, candle out
  11. 11 - told, candle out
  12. 12 - told, candle out
  13. 13 - told, candle out
  14. 14 - told, candle out
  15. 15 - told, candle out
  16. 16 - told, candle out
  17. 17 - told, candle out
  18. 18 - told, candle out
  19. 19 - told, candle out
  20. 20 - told, candle out
  21. 21 - told, candle out
  22. 22 - being told, candle burning
  23. 23 - still to tell, candle lit
  24. 24 - still to tell, candle lit

Story 425 of 466. 424 told, 41 still waiting.

Listen to the whole episode

Source: Cryptic County Listen at the source

Playing from the creator's feed

Following lives in the app.Get the app

Playlists live in the app.Get the app

All episodes: Let's Not Meet: A True Horror Podcast

Shownotes

About this episode

Stories in this episode: My Stalker Was Convinced He Was Gatsby & I Was His Daisy | justascrolling (0:38) Alone In Small Town Nowhere | TheWarDog10 (18:14) Woke Up to a Staring Man in Our Hotel Room | pugalug14 (24:02) Creepy Encounter | Wardens_Myth (30:49) My Knife Saved Me | ThatSynGirl (36:09) Minor Stop May Have Prevented Tragedy | sleepwalkfromsherdog (40:53) Barry | EndOfMe (45:03) Extended Patreon Content: Come Out and I'll Show You" | Curious_Sparrow My 9th Grade Teacher Was An Absolute Creep | Victoria Southgate The Scary Man at QT | Anonymous A Setup in Massachusetts | Lauren The Man in the Cape Cod Movie Theater | Katie J. Due to periodic changes in ad placement, time stamps are estimates and are not always accurate . Want Bonus Weekly Stories? Hate Ads? Join our Patreon for only $5 a month for over 100 hours of bonus content, and it's all ad-free! Send your stories to [redacted] . Make 2026 your cat’s healthiest year yet. Take advantage of their New Year’s Special and get 60% off your first order, plus free shipping, when you head to Smalls.com/MEET ! Right now, Wildgrain is offering our listeners $30 off your first box, PLUS free Croissants for life, when you go to Wildgrain.com/MEET to start your subscription today Join the Discord: Follow: - Twitch - - Website - - Patreon - - Instagram - All of the stories you've heard this week were narrated and produced with the permission of their respective authors. Let's Not Meet: A True Horror Podcast is not associated with Reddit or any other message boards online.

Next in the series

Keep going.

Is this your show, or something that should not be here? Report or request removal Copyright and takedown