Shownotes
About this episode
The Other Amy: Dry Sweater, Wet Grave A man falls through ice, but his girlfriend pulls him out, and he recovers. This version of the story is true, but it omits the terrifying detail he's never told: the pale, blue-tinged face of his girlfriend, Amy, staring up at him from beneath the frozen lake, wearing the same purple sweater she wore the day before. What was this chilling apparition trying to tell him? In this episode, we delve into a man's harrowing encounter on Lake Winnibigoshish, where the frozen surface held a secret. We explore the unsettling experience of seeing a familiar face trapped beneath the ice and the chilling message it conveyed, leaving us to wonder about the true nature of what he witnessed. Person: Amy Location: Lake Winnibigoshish, Northern Minnesota Temperature: Fourteen degrees Fahrenheit Object: Purple sweater Event: Encounter with a face under the ice - A man, terrified of frozen lakes, stood fifteen feet from shore on thick ice. - He heard a sound like an "ephemeral gunshot" from deep below the ice. - Through a thin patch of snow, he saw a pale, blue-tinged face pressed against the underside of the ice. - The face, wearing a purple sweater, had unnaturally blue eyes that tracked his movements. - The lips of the face moved, forming the word "Run" just as the real Amy called his name from the shore. Tired of ads? Listen to this podcast and 200+ more ad-free on OBOMEDIA. Try it free for 7 days, cancel anytime: OBOMEDIA presents real horror stories a scary story podcast for the late night hours. Every episode is horror narration done right: true scary stories and horror stories based on true events, told from the first chilling minute. Expect disturbing true stories, disturbing horror stories and dark true horror stories drawn from real testimonies. Some nights bring camping horror stories, forest horror stories and road horror stories; others bring home alone horror stories, haunted stories, eerie stories, strange stories and unsettling tales true creepy stories and creepy encounters that never made the news. Press play on our late night horror stories and late night scary stories, from storytime horror to a full horror stories compilation or scary stories compilation real scary stories, scary stories based on true events, and dark stories to keep the lights on. © 2026 Created by an independent creator of the OBOMEDIA Network, who owns and is solely responsible for this content. All rights reserved. Reproduction or commercial use without the creator's written permission is prohibited. Business: [redacted].